Merseyside | Liverpool fans analyse defeat against United

Manchester United 2 - 1 Liverpool

We asked for the thoughts of Liverpool fans after their Premier League defeat against Manchester United.

Author | William G

Stadium | Anfield

Waz: Injuries aside, there is a sense Liverpool are continually papering over the cracks under Arne Slot. The football feels slow, predictable and lacking in intensity, and it is difficult to see how that approach translates in the Premier League. Last season’s title owed much to the remnants of Jürgen Klopp’s side, but that core now appears dismantled. The absence of a clear identity is striking, and unless something shifts, concerns will only deepen.

Kevin: Liverpool’s issues this season have been widespread, affecting every area of the pitch. Recruitment stands out as the most pressing concern. There is no adequate cover for Virgil van Dijk or Ibrahima Konaté, and Conor Bradley has been left without support at right-back. Florian Wirtz has struggled to adapt and looks ill-suited to the league’s physical demands. Missing out on Marc Guéhi feels like a significant misstep, while the arrivals of Alexander Isak and Jeremie Frimpong have yet to convince. Much of the scrutiny, in that sense, falls on sporting director Richard Hughes.

Man United fan perspective

Man United fans blog @theviewfromkstand.bsky.social analyses their win over Liverpool. viewfromkstand.blogspot.com/2026/05/unit...

[image or embed]

— Super News Affiliate (@supernews1.bsky.social) 4 May 2026 at 13:16

Maz: It was a deeply underwhelming display. Even after being handed two goals early in the second half, Liverpool never looked in control. The play was laboured, the attack lacked sharpness and the defensive structure appeared disjointed. The midfield, in particular, seemed absent. Even if Slot remains beyond the summer, there is a growing feeling that his position could come under immediate pressure once the new season begins.

Darren: Were it not for United’s errors, the margin could have been far wider. The issue does not appear to be a lack of understanding from Slot, but rather a lack of urgency from the players. Aside from flashes from Rio Ngumoha and Dominik Szoboszlai, there has been little spark. Counter-attacks are either too slow or non-existent, the passing lacks direction, and opponents are afforded too much time and space. The pressing that once defined Liverpool’s game has faded, and responsibility for that, increasingly, lies with those on the pitch.

Frank: The players showed some fight to make that close in the end but the damage was already done in an utterly abysmal first half. We have produced that half far, far too many times this season.